# What a SAFE note turns into: The four endings an angel should price in

By Ozan Sonmez. Published 24 October 2026.
Canonical: https://brutallyhonestangel.com/library/safe-note-four-endings

## What is a SAFE note, and what does it turn into?

A SAFE, a simple agreement for future equity, is a short contract: you pay a startup now for the right to shares later. Y Combinator's post-money version ends in a priced round, a sale or listing, or a shutdown, and it has no maturity date. So the fourth ending is that it simply stays open.

Below is each term an angel meets in Y Combinator's forms, read from the clause that sets it, with worked numbers on a 25,000 USD cheque and what each of the four endings pays you.

## First, whose form it is

Carolynn Levy created the SAFE at Y Combinator (YC) in 2013, and the post-money version has been YC's standard since 2018. It is a US document. YC lists it among its forms for US companies, and the form names the company as a corporation of its state of incorporation, carries a US Securities Act legend, and has you state that you are an accredited investor under Rule 501 of Regulation D. YC publishes valuation cap versions for companies formed in Canada, the Cayman Islands and Singapore, and its page tells everyone to consult a lawyer licensed in the country where the company was formed.

In the UK you may meet the same idea under another name. A 2022 briefing by the London law firm Russell-Cooke said SAFEs are often called advance subscription agreements (ASAs) there, and recommended a version written for UK law over YC's US documents. If you want EIS relief, HMRC's manual sets the bar: it will not consider an ASA suitable unless the payment cannot be refunded under any circumstances, the agreement cannot be varied, cancelled or assigned, it carries no interest, and it has a longstop date for issuing the shares, which HMRC, as a general rule, expects to be no more than six months away. Put that next to the YC form, which can pay your money back in a sale or a shutdown, can be amended and has no end date. Then ask the company's lawyer which instrument you are signing before you count on the relief.

## The glossary: terms on the first page

### Purchase amount

The money you pay. It is the term that other SAFE holders can never change for you as a group (see majority-in-interest below).

### Post-money valuation cap

The highest valuation at which your SAFE converts. On the post-money form your ownership is your purchase amount divided by the cap: 25,000 USD at a 5 million USD cap is 0.5% of the company. YC's user guide calls that transparency the form's biggest advantage.

The number has two limits. The cap sits after all the SAFE money and after the option pool that existed before the priced round, so SAFEs do not dilute each other. The new money in the priced round does dilute you, and so does any new or larger option pool adopted with it. If that round's new investors and new pool take 30% of the company between them, your 0.5% becomes 0.35%. The stakes also add up across investors. YC's own warning: five 100,000 USD SAFEs at a 5 million USD cap sell 10% of the company.

### Discount

On the discount form, the "Discount Rate" is 100 minus the discount, and you convert at the round's lowest price multiplied by that rate. At a 20% discount and a round price of 1.00 USD a share, you pay 0.80 USD, so 25,000 USD buys 31,250 shares where a new investor gets 25,000. YC's page says discounts are commonly 10 to 20%. YC removed its combined cap and discount form in 2021, so each US form today carries a cap, a discount or neither.

### MFN

Short for "most favoured nation". The MFN form has no cap and no discount. If the company later issues convertible securities on better terms, it must send you written notice, and you have 10 days to tell it in writing that you want those terms, after which it amends your SAFE to match. YC's guide adds two limits: you take the later instrument whole, with no picking of terms, and you typically get one chance. Side letters that leave the economic terms alone do not trigger it. YC's web page sums this up as automatic; the form itself asks you to choose within the 10 days.

### Pro rata side letter

Pro rata rights sit in a separate letter that you have to ask for. It gives you the right to buy your pro rata share of the preferred stock sold in the priced round where your SAFE converts: your conversion shares divided by the Company Capitalization (see below). The right ends at that round's first closing, and it only works with forms that have a post-money cap. YC's guide asks investors who hold it to commit or pass quickly once the company says it is raising.

## Ending one: a priced round

### Equity Financing

The form's name for a priced round: a bona fide raise in which the company sells preferred stock at a fixed valuation. The post-money SAFE sets no minimum size for it, and conversion is automatic at the round's first closing.

### Safe Price and Company Capitalization

You receive the larger of two share counts: your purchase amount divided by the round's lowest price per share, or divided by the "Safe Price", which is the cap divided by the "Company Capitalization". That denominator counts every issued share, every converting security (this SAFE, other SAFEs, convertible notes), all granted and promised options and the unissued pool. A pool increase made for the round counts only where promised options exceed the old pool. If the round's pre-money valuation is below your cap, the round's own price gives you more shares and the cap does not apply.

### Safe Preferred Stock

When the cap applies, you receive a separate series of the round's preferred stock, which YC's guide notes is sometimes called shadow preferred. It has the same rights, seniority and liquidation multiple as the new investors' shares, with the per-share amounts based on your lower price. YC added the liquidation multiple to that definition in February 2023. When the round's price wins, you receive the same standard preferred stock as the new investors. Either way, you sign the round's documents, provided they are the ones the new investors sign.

## Ending two: a sale or a listing

### Liquidity Event

A change of control (including someone acquiring more than 50% of the voting securities), a direct listing or an IPO. You receive the greater of the "Cash-Out Amount", which is your purchase amount, and the "Conversion Amount", which is what you would get as common stock converted at the cap.

The clause gives you a quick test. The conversion amount wins when the sale pays more per common share than the "Liquidity Price": the cap divided by the "Liquidity Capitalization", the shares counted at the sale. Say 10 million shares are counted: a 5 million USD cap gives a Liquidity Price of 0.50 USD, and your 25,000 USD counts as 50,000 shares. If the sale pays 0.40 USD a share, the conversion amount is 20,000 USD and you take your 25,000 back. At 2.00 USD a share it is 100,000 USD.

The money-back floor has a queue. YC's guide puts the SAFE behind creditors and outstanding debt, convertible notes included, with the same priority as standard non-participating preferred stock.

## Ending three: a shutdown

### Dissolution Event

The company stops operating voluntarily, assigns its assets for the benefit of its creditors, or is otherwise wound up. You are entitled to your purchase amount from the proceeds legally available for distribution. Debt and creditor claims come first. You rank level with other SAFEs and preferred stock, sharing in proportion if there is not enough for all of you, and ahead of common stock.

We treat this clause as a legal right, and we do not treat it as a likely outcome. How much a young company has left once its debts are paid is the open question, and the document cannot answer it for you.

## Ending four: it never converts

### Maturity date

There is none. YC's guide says the SAFE terminates only when you have received stock, cash or other proceeds in one of the three events above, and that in theory it could stay outstanding for a long time.

While it stays open, four clauses decide your position:

1. No vote. Until shares are issued to you, you have no right to vote for directors, to consent to company actions or to receive notice of meetings. The one payment written in is a dividend: if the company pays one on its common stock in a form other than shares, you receive your share at the same time. YC added that clause for companies that become sustainable, cash flow positive businesses without a venture exit in sight.
2. Majority-in-interest. The company can amend your SAFE with the holders of more than 50% of the money on SAFEs with the same cap and discount as yours. Your purchase amount cannot be changed this way, every holder's consent must be asked for, and all must be treated the same. If 750,000 USD sits on your 5 million USD cap, one investor holding 400,000 USD of it can sign for the whole group, alongside the company.
3. Transfer. You cannot sell or assign the SAFE without the company's written consent, except to your estate or heirs on death or disability, or to an entity that controls you, that you control or that shares common control with you.
4. The side exit. If you are not an accredited investor at the time of the priced round, the company may void the SAFE and return your purchase amount.

We read those limits as the trade a simple form makes, and knowing them is how you price that trade.

## Pricing the four endings

These five steps work on a SAFE you are about to sign or already hold. We read the valuation cap form clause by clause, with you in the investor's seat, in our Angels Beacon episode [Four endings written into your SAFE](https://open.spotify.com/episode/1CqQoYeMgxjUslrzoZuI1p).

1. Divide your purchase amount by the cap and write the percentage down. That is your stake just before the priced round.
2. Ask the company how much other money sits on the same cap, and who holds the largest piece of it. That tells you who could amend your SAFE alongside the company.
3. Price the shutdown ending at what a wind-down would really leave, after debt.
4. On an MFN, put the 10-day window in your calendar the day the notice arrives.
5. If you want to follow on, ask for the pro rata letter now, and decide before the round opens whether you will use it.

A SAFE sets your terms. Whether the company deserves them is a separate check, and it is the check we built our [startup assessment platform](https://brutallyhonestangel.com/assessment) for.

> Part of: First-time angels. Next in this cluster: [How to become an angel investor: Thesis, cheque size and the first ten deals](https://brutallyhonestangel.com/library/how-to-become-an-angel-investor), and Angel due diligence checklist: The four areas to check before you wire money.

## Where we fit

The Brutally Honest Angel runs a startup assessment platform for angel investors and startup mentors who apply and are approved. You invite a company's founders, each co-founder answers separately, and the report shows scores on four dimensions, the alignment between the founders and the flagged answers that need a closer look. Approved accounts start on the free plan, with 1 evaluation and 50 AI Analyst credits a month. We take no equity and sell no deal flow or investment advice. [See how the assessment platform works](https://brutallyhonestangel.com/assessment), or [apply for a free investor account from the platform page](https://assessment.brutallyhonestangel.com/).

## Questions angels ask

### What happens if a SAFE never converts?

On Y Combinator's post-money SAFE, nothing ends it on a date. It has no maturity date, and YC's user guide says it could in theory stay outstanding for a long time. It ends only in a priced round, a sale or listing, or a shutdown. Until then, the one payment written into it is your share of any dividend the company pays on its common stock in a form other than shares.

### What is the difference between a SAFE and a convertible note?

Y Combinator describes a convertible note as debt: interest accrues and the note has a maturity date set for repayment or forced conversion. Its SAFE has no interest and no maturity date. In a sale or a shutdown the difference shows up in the queue, because the SAFE form puts outstanding convertible notes, as debt, ahead of the SAFE.

### Are SAFE notes considered debt?

Y Combinator says its SAFE is neither a debt nor a loan, and that it is not stock until it converts into preferred shares in a priced round. The form also records that, for US federal and state income tax, the parties intend it to be treated as stock. Outside the US, ask a tax adviser in your own country how it is treated.

## Sources

- Y Combinator, [The SAFE: The standard way startups raise money](https://www.ycombinator.com/safe), live page, read 21 October 2026.
- Y Combinator, [SAFE vs. convertible note vs. priced round](https://www.ycombinator.com/safe/safe-vs-convertible-note), live page, read 21 October 2026.
- Y Combinator, [Post-Money SAFE User Guide](https://www.ycombinator.com/safe#downloads), version 1.2, February 2023.
- Y Combinator, [Postmoney Safe: Valuation Cap Only](https://www.ycombinator.com/safe#downloads), version 1.2, February 2023.
- Y Combinator, [Postmoney Safe: Discount Only](https://www.ycombinator.com/safe#downloads), version 1.2, February 2023.
- Y Combinator, [Postmoney Safe: MFN Only](https://www.ycombinator.com/safe#downloads), version 1.3, February 2023.
- Y Combinator, [Pro Rata Side Letter](https://www.ycombinator.com/safe#downloads), version 1.0, September 2018.
- HM Revenue and Customs, [VCM12025: EIS: income tax relief: general requirements: advance subscription agreements](https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/venture-capital-schemes-manual/vcm12025), Venture Capital Schemes Manual, last public update 15 March 2021, read 21 October 2026.
- Russell-Cooke, [Part 1: SAFEs (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) and advance subscription agreements](https://www.russell-cooke.co.uk/news-and-insights/news/part-1-safes-simple-agreement-for-future-equity-and-advance-subscription-agreements), 25 April 2022.
- Angels Beacon by TBHA, [Four endings written into your SAFE](https://open.spotify.com/episode/1CqQoYeMgxjUslrzoZuI1p), 19 October 2026.

This page is educational content and is not investment advice.
