Partner: your AI teamSee what it does

    Skip to content

    Where do I start as a first-⁠time angel investor?

    Ozan SonmezUpdated 10 min readWebsiteLinkedIn

    How do you become an angel investor?

    Set a total angel budget you could lose in full, then write a thesis built on the industries and the people you know. Keep half the budget for follow-on rounds and spread the other half across about ten first cheques over three to four years. Write your follow-on rules before the first money leaves your account.

    This page puts the advice we give new angels in the order we would make the decisions, with a worked budget to redo with your own numbers.

    What the returns data says before you start

    In November 2007, Robert Wiltbank and Warren Boeker published a study of 539 angels from 86 North American angel groups, with support from the Kauffman Foundation. Their 1,137 exits ran from 1990 to 2007, 62% of them after 2004, and the authors noted that angels who failed and left their groups could be missing. Read the numbers as a picture of one market in one period:

    • 52% of the exits returned less than the angel had invested.
    • 7% returned more than ten times the money, and those exits produced 75% of all the cash returned.
    • The average was 2.6 times the money in 3.5 years.
    • Even so, 61% of the angels had portfolios that returned more than they put in, which the authors put down to the advantage of holding a portfolio.

    The losses also came first. Exits below the money took three years on average, and those above 30 times took six. The authors concluded that in any single venture, an angel was more likely to lose money than to make it.

    That is why we treat angel investing as a portfolio game. We also plan for five to seven years from a first cheque to an exit, and that is on a good day. If you need the money back sooner, or the thought of losing it keeps you up at night, keep it out of startups.

    Step 1: Write a thesis from what you know and who you know

    A thesis is the list of deals you will say yes to, written before the deals arrive. In our view it has to come from your own working life: the industries you know from the inside, the business models you have run or sold to, and the people in decision-making roles who would take your call. Topics you have read a few books on, or follow online, make a weak base.

    The 2007 data points the same way. Half of the investments in the study were unrelated to the angel's industry experience, and the multiples were twice as high on the ones connected to the angel's expertise.

    Write it on one page (the examples are illustrations).

    Line What to write Example
    Industries Where you have worked or sold, with years Retail banking, 15 years
    Business models Models you understand from the inside Software sold to banks and insurers
    Geographies Markets where you can open doors Türkiye and the Gulf
    People Decision-makers who would take your call Heads of operations at six banks
    What you add Help beyond money Introductions for pilots, hiring for regulated roles
    Outside the thesis What you will not judge alone Life sciences, consumer apps

    We think founders look for capital that brings know-how and open doors with it, so the "what you add" line deserves as much care as the money. For a deal outside the page, you can still invest, but do it next to a lead who knows the field, with a smaller cheque, and admit to yourself that you are following.

    Step 2: Set the budget, then split it in half

    How much should an angel investor invest? Start from the total, and only then work out the cheque.

    The total is money you could lose in full without changing how you live. Paul Graham applied the same test to each cheque in 2009: as a beginner, keep each investment small enough that you would not care too much about losing it. His example was 15,000 dollars per cheque for someone with 5 million dollars of investable assets, three or four of them to start, with the first few treated as an education.

    Then split the total. Our rule is to keep at least half of the angel budget for follow-on rounds and spread the other half over about ten first cheques, so each first cheque is one twentieth of the total. The numbers below are illustrations:

    Line Rule 200,000 EUR budget 60,000 EUR budget
    Follow-on reserve At least half 100,000 EUR 30,000 EUR
    First-cheque pool The other half 100,000 EUR 30,000 EUR
    Each first cheque Pool divided by ten 10,000 EUR 3,000 EUR
    Pace About one a quarter 10 quarters 10 quarters
    Follow-on per company Reserve divided by the companies that earn one 25,000 to 33,000 EUR if three or four do 7,500 to 10,000 EUR if three or four do

    Nobody knows in advance how many of the ten will earn a second cheque, so the last line is there to show the scale. Write the rule in step 4 and let the reserve wait for it.

    If 3,000 EUR is below what the rounds you see will take from one person, pool it. Graham's easiest way in was to find a friend who already invests and get included in their syndicates. In our view a small budget can also start with advice and introductions, which can earn a small advisory stake before any money moves.

    Step 3: Pace the first ten deals

    We plan for about ten investments in three to four years, roughly one a quarter. At one a year, a ten-company portfolio takes a decade. In the 2007 study, the typical angel in a group had been investing for just over nine years and had made slightly more than one investment a year.

    Ten deals with one winner assumed is still a guess, and as we see it, the process behind each cheque decides more than the count.

    The deals come through people. Go to the events, competitions and pitch nights where founders show up, and spend time with angels who already hold portfolios. Without a network you decide alone, and we think that is where fear of missing out gets in. In Europe, EBAN, the European Business Angel Network, is an association of business angel networks and one place to look for a group near you.

    Step 4: Write the follow-on rules before the first cheque

    We expect that after about three years of steady cheques, a few of your companies will look more valuable, at least on paper. The rights you got in the first round are worth something only if you have the cash to use them, and we see that second cheque, into a company that is already working, as the less risky one.

    The same reserve can also lose you money. One sure way, in our view, is the falling knife: putting more into a struggling company because you are afraid of losing the first cheque, and it seems so close to its goal.

    The 2007 data is a warning too. The angels followed on in 29% of the ventures they exited. Those ventures returned 1.4 times the money, against 3.6 times for the rest, and 68% of the exits that took a follow-on lost capital. The authors added that refusing to invest again can finish off a struggling company, so a follow-on can still be the right call, and that more research might be needed.

    So decide on the day you write each first cheque:

    1. The trigger. The milestones that would earn a second cheque, taken from the founders' own targets.
    2. The information. Metrics, written updates, and a call or a coffee each quarter, even without a board seat.
    3. The size. The most you would hold back for this company.
    4. The right. Whether the first round lets you invest again.
    5. The stop. What would make you say no to more money, written while you are calm.

    On Y Combinator's SAFE, the right is a separate document. Its standard keeps pro rata rights, the option to invest in a later priced round and keep your percentage, in an optional side letter outside the SAFE itself, and its page tells founders that an investor buying a 500,000 dollar SAFE has a good case for them, compared with one investing 10,000 dollars. Ask for the side letter with your first cheque anyway, and plan the reserve for either answer. We set out what a SAFE can turn into in the four endings an angel should price in.

    The Angel Capital Association's 2026 Angel Funders Report, built from member data across the US and Canada, found angel groups writing larger cheques into fewer companies, with follow-on investments attracting increasingly larger commitments. Decide your own split on paper before the first deal.

    Before each cheque: Conviction or fear of missing out

    In our experience, fear of missing out is the most common reason a first-time angel says yes quickly, and the excitement is usually about money. So treat "everyone is excited about this deal" as a warning sign. If you cannot understand the business model, help the company or talk to the founders in their own terms, the deal sits outside your thesis however good it sounds.

    Excitement is fine. Anxiety is the signal to stop. Conviction comes from the preparation in steps 1 to 4. And if a deal looks obviously good to everyone in the room, ask why nobody bigger has funded it yet.

    Run five questions before you wire the money:

    1. Is it inside my written thesis?
    2. Could I ask the founders a sharp question about their market today?
    3. Does the cheque match my first-cheque size, with the reserve untouched?
    4. Have I written the follow-on rule for this company?
    5. If the money is lost, what will I still have?

    For the last one, we suggest scoring each deal on four Fs: fun (the people and the conversations), fame (being seen as part of it), fortune (the money) and future (a stake in something that matters for the years ahead). A deal that scores only on fortune leaves you nothing if it fails.

    Then put in the hours. The median due diligence in the 2007 study was 20 hours per investment. Angels who spent more than that earned an overall 5.9 times the money, against 1.1 times for those who spent less, and the authors found time on due diligence significantly related to better outcomes. Part of those hours can be the founders' own answers: on our startup assessment platform, each co-founder answers separately, and the report shows scores on four dimensions, the alignment between the founders and the answers that were flagged.

    Work through it with us

    The Brutally Honest Angel's startup assessment platform is for angel investors and startup mentors who apply and are approved. The free plan includes 1 evaluation and 50 AI Analyst credits a month, and paid plans run from 25 EUR a month for 2 evaluations to 375 EUR for 50, VAT included. See how the platform works, or apply for an account from the platform page.

    To talk your investing strategy, a founder you are assessing or a live deal through with us, 1:1 investor coaching is a 60-minute session on Zoom for 350 EUR, VAT included. The Brutally Honest Angel takes no equity and sells no deal flow or investment advice.

    Questions angels ask

    Can you make money being an angel investor?

    Yes. In a 2007 study of 539 North American angels in groups, 61% had portfolios that made money, even though 52% of exits returned less than was invested. The money came from a few deals: 7% of exits returned more than ten times and produced 75% of the cash returned, which is why we plan for about ten deals.

    How much should an angel investor invest in one startup?

    Start from the total you could lose in full. Keep at least half of it for follow-on rounds and divide the rest across about ten first cheques, so each first cheque is one twentieth of the total. With an angel budget of 200,000 EUR, that is 10,000 EUR per first cheque and 100,000 EUR held back.

    Can you become an angel investor with little money?

    Yes. Scale the method down and keep its shape: pool small cheques through a syndicate or an angel network's group deals, keep half for follow-ons and spread the rest across about ten companies. In our view you can also start with advice and introductions, which can earn a small advisory stake before any money moves.

    How should an angel investor evaluate a startup before investing?

    Check the deal against your written thesis, your first-cheque size and the follow-on rule you wrote for the company, then put in the hours. In a 2007 study of angels in groups, the median due diligence was 20 hours per investment, and angels who spent more than that earned 5.9 times their money overall, against 1.1 times for those who spent less.

    Sources

    This page is educational content and not investment advice.

    Next in this topic

    More from the library